The State of “Green” Printing
Myself and many of my fine art printing clients are conscious of the environmental impact of fine art printing. Through my research, I have not yet found any acceptable environmentally-conscious solutions to mitigate either the impact of the production of electronic equipment such as printers or the production of the inks used in color printing.
Paper, however, is one area where one can make an environmentally-friendly choice without sacrificing quality of the end result. The venerable German paper company Hahnemühle has recently introduced two new papers that I find to provide very high print quality with a significantly reduced environmental impact.
Their environmental bona fides come partially from their component materials. Hahnemühle Fine Art Bamboo Paper is made from 90% bamboo (a highly renewable resource) and 10% recycled cotton rag. Hahnemühle Fine Art Sugar Cane Paper is made of 75% of sugar cane waste byproduct (called bagasse) and 25% recycled cotton from Hahnemühle’s own mills. Hahnemühle also uses 100% recycled materials for packaging, renewable energy to produce the paper, and donates a portion of sales to environmental projects. You can find many details of their environmental efforts at their oddly named but highly informative Green Rooster site.
My favorite of the two papers is Hahnemühle Fine Art Bamboo. Available in all standard sizes in both sheet and roll, Bamboo provides a reasonably heavy weight (290 gsm) matte paper with a lovely lightly textured surface and decided warmtone due to its lack of optical brighteners (OBAs). It is similar in print quality in many ways to Hahnemühle’s ubiquitous Photo Rag but significantly warmer in tone and with a smoother surface and a bit more dynamic range. I recommend this paper for warmer images, particularly natural scenes, as well as warm-toned black & white work for which it is particularly lovely.
Hahnemühle Fine Art Sugar Cane is another excellent matte paper that is environmentally sensible. A slightly heavier paper than Bamboo that is also available in all standard sizes and formats, Sugar Cane’s biggest distinction is its more heavily textured surface. The surface is a bit hard to describe but it makes me think of a subtle directional weave. I personally prefer a smoother surface such as that of the Bamboo paper, but such a preference is a personal one and others may prefer Sugar Cane for certain applications. I plan on using it with some clients for specific projects where its unique textured surface can be a distinct advantage. Sugar Cane is free from OBA’s but not nearly as warm as Bamboo (though still warmer than neutral).
Hahnemühle should be applauded for taking leadership in mitigating their environmental impact and hopefully other manufacturers will follow suit. Please comment if you have experience with either of these papers or if you know of any other available papers with reduced environmental impact.
- Jim Nickelson
Jim Nickelson Photography & Nickelson Editions
July 2, 2010 at 2:52 am
and what do you think of their pearl paper?
July 2, 2010 at 5:34 pm
Susan,
Thanks for your comment. I have very little experience with their Pearl paper, unfortunately. The similar paper that I do use quite a bit is their Photo Rag Baryta paper, which is my favorite of the ‘lustre’ papers from any manufacturer. I did try their Satin paper and didn’t care much for the surface (from an entirely subjective point of view). I suspect Photo Rag Baryta is not too far from the Pearl paper in many ways except that Pearl is brighter/whiter and I believe has a little flatter surface – but I haven’t investigated the Pearl too much at this point because I generally prefer the rag papers versus alpha cellulose and papers without OBA’s to ones that do.
I definitely appreciate the question as that is a paper I should investigate further. Do you have any thoughts on it or are you thinking of trying it yourself?
Thanks again!
Jim Nickelson